I have a great idea, but I can’t tell you

by Jeff Haynie on August 22, 2007 · Comments

Since I blog a good deal about entrepreneurship, I receive emails from would-be business people who want to take the plunge, live the dream, making the leap – become a startup entrepreneur. Some of them, have decent credentials from a big company standpoint. And often, they lead in with how wonderful their idea is and how it will change the world – and how they can’t tell me what it is (but it’s big!).

OK, first off, regardless of my good-hearted jabs – I think this is incredibly wonderful and reminds me of a decade ago when I used to receive all the incoming ideas at eHatchery – a local incubator where I was CTO. I often get incredibly detailed emails that give me almost no idea of even how to respond. I often respond something like this: “there’s little to no value in your idea, execution is all that matters. if you don’t feel comfortable sharing your idea with me, that’s OK. i have about a million ideas of my own I don’t have time to execute on, i really don’t care to try and add yours to the list.
I’m not sure what else to say…

there’s little to no value in your idea, execution is all that matters.

The idea of sharing your golden egg with the rest of the world, I realize, is scary. I think it’s especially scary when you have little ability to execute: no capital, a full-time job and you need programmers. Yeah, that’s pretty scary. But, remember: there’s like 6 billion people in the world. You’re probably not the only one that’s thought about what you’re thinking about. And, maybe even some have gotten further than you – I know, hard to believe. That’s not to say that your idea isn’t good and you should keep your day job. It does mean that ideas in your head most likely will just stay there – and turn into a lot of frustration.

The only way to take a good idea to reality is execution. And, if you’re stuck in your day job with a great idea and no ability to execute – well, maybe you need to either find out a way to make it happen, or get back to work. No offense intended, really.

Entrepreneurs find a way. They make it happen. They don’t always know either – and most of the times enter into things with no freaking clue how they’ll make it happen. They show up like they’ve figured it out and make the corrections as they need to. If you can’t get going, maybe you should stay home – you might not be an entrepreneur. And, that doesn’t mean your idea sucks – it just might not mean you’re the guy to make it happen by yourself.

To me, at the end of the day, all that matters is execution and results. Figure out how to try and make it happen – even if you can’t quit your day job initially. If you can’t figure out how to get your first $50K, you’re probably going to panic when you have to raise the next $1M and quit anyway. If you don’t know any “programmer’s to do the work at equity” as I often am told, well, you’re probably not ready to take the plunge. In a big company, others are responsible for everything else except what you’re responsible for. In a startup, everyone is responsible for everybody else’s stuff – we all do it and we all have to make it happen – or it fails and we have to do something else that sucks. I’ve started 8 companies and I can tell you – my biggest fear is not if I’ll fail and I won’t take home a paycheck. My fear: I’ll have to go work for IBM. I swear to you, I worry more that I’ll have to one day go work at some deadend job, sitting in a cube, a cog in the wheel – a big blob of nothing. I always joke with my wife: “don’t worry, worse case I’ll have to work 30 hours a week a draw a nice salary with benefits”. Of course, I realize, not everyone has that fall-back (or at least, they don’t perceive to).

all that matters is execution and results

Can’t you just make it happen – at least get it going – before you look around to others to take some risk on your behalf? This isn’t saying reach out for help, just don’t reach out with your hand looking for a paycheck before you quit your job. I understand, we all have a lifestyle to maintain – we all don’t want to worry about how to pay our mortgages. But, c’mon. If you can’t make it on your own, you’re not going to be able to build a company and support others. And, just because you got that big $1M investment, doesn’t mean it’s an easy road from there. Most people assume when you raise capital, you’re done. Back to work. Focus on the product. Just make the business work – easy street now. Are you kidding? You don’t realize how much time you’ll spend focused on what happens when the $1M runs out – because now you realize, that $1M isn’t too much and that as you add people (and the resulting burn), you’ll quickly need more. You’ll now also realize that it took so long to get the first money that if you don’t start in 3 months again, you might not have enough time for to get the next round closed. Yea, the cycle begins. Been there, done that.

You gotta figure out how to get your product going and get some revenue – any amount of revenue – to validate what you’re trying to do. Yeah, I know – it’s going to take time and money – and people besides yourself. Get it going, please, and I promise it’ll be a much easier rider. Get it going and it’ll be easier to hire others, raise money and acquire help. Keep it in your head, and you’ll only be frustrated. And lose the idea that investors and other entrepreneurs are just looking for other people’s good ideas to steal. Crap, we’ve got enough of our own ideas and issues to worry about your next Google. :)

Are you an existing business that needs an eMarketing jolt? Entreprenuer magazine and Caffeine Marketing Jolt are having a content for $20K. You can get more details from Brent Leary’s Technology for Business Sake’s podcast show. Brent’s a partner at Atlanta-based CRM Essentials and a judge for the content. If you haven’t checked out Brent’s weekly show – you should – he’s got top notch and high profile guests with a wealth of good information.

Technorati technorati tags: , , , , ,

Popularity: 19% [?]

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

  • ukollieboy
    Hey was browsing and came across this article. I am 29 and have four kids and want to to give them a good life , up until i read your article i had just about given up the idea. Thanks.
  • An element I ask entrepreneurs to consider when they ask me about revealing their ideas is if their idea is so easy to replicate, that anyone hearing it can steal it and execute it successfully, is the idea itself really that strong after all?

    There needs to be something unique about the entrepreneur and his/her resources that is the catalyst for transforming an idea into a viable business.

    We actually had one person ask us a couple of days ago of the perils of revealing his idea to investors at Capital Connections. I guess the only foolproof way to not have someone steal his idea is to stay home. A fat load of value the idea has in that case!
  • Good post - two quick things to add.

    1. With certain friends, I'm the "business guy" so every time they get an idea they tell me. What I've realized about help from others is - you have to take it as far as you possibly can, by yourself before you can really expect someone else to help you. sure I talk with friends about ideas, but my advice is almost always that I'm sure someone else is doing that. Google your idea and find out who else is doing it. This is something easy that anyone can do.

    2. I'm working on the next great big idea, who isn't. I am usually not paranoid, but the closer I get to launch the less I want to tell the idea. Maybe there are less people that can actually help me, maybe I'm worried about not being the first to market. Either way I guess the "That's a great idea" from people just isn't as important until the marketing starts.
  • tats
    "You gotta figure out how to get your product going and get some revenue - any amount of revenue - to validate what you’re trying to do."

    Perfect! I've been creating for 15 months so far & I'm still going strong, this post carries me a little further -thanks Jeff
  • Any idiot can generate ideas. The trophy goes to those who can execute on them.

    I actually credit, you (Jeff), with empowering me to take the plunge. That dinner at Maggiano's was a good dose of tough-love that was the catalyst that started it all, and we've been a steam-roller ever since!

    So, Jeff, if you fail miserably with future endeavors and end up a pauper, at least you can look back and say you had a positive impact on LoopFuse. Thats worth something, right? ;-)
  • Matt Peterson
    Jeff, thanks for the great perspective. It certainly does get the wheels turning about finding creative ways to get the ball rolling.
  • Bravo! You boiled down the essence of entrepreneurship to one sentence - "Entrepreneurs find a way." To me, being an entrepreneur is being convinced you're going to succeed (and making it happen) when everybody else tells you you're going to fail. It's amazing what happens when you start creating a product - the other pieces you worry about start falling into place.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post: How not to treat your customers

Next post: Mashup your pictures into awesome videos